01 / RULES FIRST
FIG. 1 · THE LINE
The legal line moves when you log in
On public pages, US courts have been friendly to scraping. Behind a login, two things change, and
every serious answer to this question starts with them.
CHANGE 1
You agreed to the terms
Creating the account meant accepting terms of service, and courts enforce clickwrap contracts.
If the ToS prohibits automated access, scraping is a contract issue even when it is not a
criminal one. For a portal run by your own supplier, the fix is often one email: most vendors
will confirm in writing that automating your own account's data is fine.
CHANGE 2
"Authorized" is now the whole question
The CFAA punishes access "without authorization." Public pages, per the hiQ v. LinkedIn line
of cases, are open to all. Behind a login, your authorization comes from the account itself:
your credentials, your data, your entitlement. Using someone else's account, buying scraped
credentials, or continuing after access is revoked is on the wrong side of that word.
The safe harbor in practice: automate accounts you own, for data you are entitled to see, at gentle
frequency, with the ToS read and, where it matters, permission in writing. The broader landscape is in
is web scraping legal.